I’m back with another smudge test!
This time round, I’ll be checking out the pencil liners in my make-up collection. Eyeliner is a must-have in my daily routine because my eyes really need that extra depth, but liquid liners are not always my kind of thing to struggle with in the morning. As a result, I have ended up amassing pencil eyeliners in a bid to find one that works for my oily eyelids.
Products swatched and tested:
Innisfree Always New Auto Liner
Etude House Play 101 pencil
If I had to rank the products by how smudge-proof they are, it would be like this:
- TFS Inkgel Pencil Eyeliner
- Etude House Play 101 pencil
- Colourpop Crème Gel Liner
- Innisfree Always New Auto Liner
Are there are any other products you’d like to see being swatched and put through the smudge test? Comment and let me know! ~
8 Comments
I love colourpop! It’s my favorite brand! I will have to try those out!
I love Colourpop too!
Thanks for posting this! I’m always on the lookout for a new liner because my lids also get oily.
NYX Pencil liner waterproof in the shade Golden Olive SL05
Have you ever tried out any waterproof liners? Those are pretty smudge proof and they last through just about anything!
Hii..this is Aditi from the tanskinhelp from India. Thank you so much for being the first beauty blogger to follow my blog.. I was thrilled beyond words.. so sweet of you to think of me..
I have oily eyelids and I need those smudgeproof liners in my life.. thank you!
Hii Vivian, this is Aditi from tanskinhelp from India.. thank you so much for being the first beauty blogger to follow me.. I was thrilled beyond words.. so sweet of you!!
My eyelids are so oily I need those smudgeproof liners on my eyes.. thank you!
Eyeliner is my favourite makeup product. Over the past 8 years I’ve tried so many. I’ve never tried these pencils but I’m interested in how they’d last on my waterline. Liquid is definitely best on the lid 🙂